1The situation

An older home with peeling paint almost everywhere

The owner of a single-family home on Cleveland's east side, built around 1900, needed a Lead Safe Certificate. Like most homes that age, it had chipping and peeling paint on windows, doors, walls, stairs, the attic and the front porch.

48
painted surfaces with damaged paint
The question: how many of them actually contain lead?
2The choice

Two ways to assess the home

Both are done by a state-licensed risk assessor and both can lead to a Lead Safe Certificate. The difference is whether we test the paint itself.

Essential Assessment

  • Visual inspection: the assessor records every surface with chipping, peeling or worn paint.
  • Dust wipes: samples from floors and window sills go to a certified lab to measure lead in household dust.
  • Soil check: bare soil near the house is noted and sampled if needed.
The catch: without testing the paint, state rules require us to assume every damaged surface contains lead.

Comprehensive Assessment

  • Everything in Essential, plus:
  • XRF paint testing: the assessor holds a handheld X-ray fluorescence (XRF) analyzer against each damaged surface. In seconds it measures the lead in every layer of paint, even old layers buried under newer paint.
  • Nothing is scraped or damaged, and results are known on the spot.
The payoff: we know exactly which surfaces contain lead and which don't.

This owner chose the Comprehensive Assessment.

4What it meant for the repair bill

The work needed to get certified

If the paint had been assumed to be lead
$30,000+
  • All 48 damaged surfaces repaired as lead hazards
  • A lead-certified contractor scraping, replacing and repainting windows, doors, walls, stairs and the porch throughout the house
  • Weeks of work with plastic containment and specialty cleanup
After testing the paint
Under $1,000
  • Lead-safe repairs limited to the handful of surfaces that actually contain lead
  • No lead-safe repairs needed on the 42 surfaces that tested below the limit
  • A quick, focused job instead of a whole-house project
Non-lead paint still deserves attention

Peeling paint that tested below the lead limit isn't a lead hazard, but we still recommend scraping and repainting it as part of normal upkeep. It protects the wood underneath and keeps the home in good shape. The difference is that it can be done on your own schedule, without the cost of lead-certified contractors.

Illustrative example based on a real Lake Erie Lead Services assessment; identifying details removed. Repair costs are estimates and vary by property and contractor.

The takeaway

Pay a little more up front. Save big on the back end.

A Comprehensive Assessment costs marginally more than an Essential one. But the repairs are where the real money goes, and testing makes sure you only pay to fix the paint that actually contains lead.

Up front
Slightly higher assessment cost

The added XRF paint testing is done during the same visit.

On the back end
Potentially thousands saved on repairs

Surfaces that test below the lead limit don't need lead-safe repairs to get certified. In older homes, that's often most of them.

Not sure which is right for your property? Call us. We'll tell you honestly which one makes sense.